Product

  • Roast my idea
  • Leaderboard
  • Graveyard
  • Blog
  • Compare

Legal

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • For AI

From the blog

How to Validate a Startup IdeaWhy Most Startup Ideas FailWill People Pay for My Idea?How to Find Your Idea's Fatal FlawMy Startup Idea Already ExistsWhen to Kill a Startup IdeaStartup Idea Validation ChecklistWhy ChatGPT Can't Validate Your IdeaIs Your Startup Idea Too Niche?WorthBuild vs IdeaRoast
IDEAROASTLaunching soon on ShipBoostDang.ai
Made in Seoul · hello@idearoast.dev
Skip to main content
IDEAROAST
LeaderboardComparePricingBundlesBlogDocs
Roast →Roast my idea →

Case Registry

Every idea that went through the panel.

Ranked by survival score. Most ideas don't make it.

Total roasted

500

Avg score

3.4/10

Survived

0 of 500

Verdict:
Panel:
Sort:
426
ROASTEDFree Triage

“A platform for SMB's to put out P2P orders for creators to promote on tiktok. Options such as our page or your page, flat fee vs. commission available”

Middleman marketplace, no wedge, no buyer, creators and SMBs already have better ways to make these deals.

2/10
15d ago
427
ROASTEDFree Triage

“New saas idea roaster”

Feature, not company, free AI already roasts ideas, and founders rarely pay for criticism.

2/10
15d ago
428
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Social media app for ADHD people”

Strong need, weak wedge, ADHD-friendly is a feature set until you name the behavior existing apps fail to support.

2/10
15d ago
429
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Un SaaS pour la création d’agents et l’utilisateur connecté des outils lui même”

Crowded market, no wedge, no buyer, agent builders are free, so the integration layer must be your whole company.

2/10
15d ago
430
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Un SaaS pour la création d’agents et l’utilisateur connecté des outils lui même”

Marché saturé, sans client précis ni douleur unique, ton agent builder sera invisible face aux plateformes déjà installées.

2/10
15d ago
431
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Un SaaS pour la création d’agents et l’utilisateur connecté des outils lui même”

Marché encombré, proposition floue, sans segment précis vous construisez un agent parmi quarante autres.

2/10
15d ago
432
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Un SaaS pour la création d’agents et l’utilisateur connecté des outils lui même”

Real category, no wedge, you are packaging a feature users already get cheaper elsewhere.

2/10
15d ago
433
ROASTEDFree Triage

“It is an app similar to mistplay and so onbut focused only in the middle-east, we will reward players based on milestones from other games maybe bank accounts and so on we have the ability to bring in users for very cheap and convert them to other places”

Thin wedge, bad engine, unless local payment rails are the product, you'll subsidize churn with no durable margin.

2/10
15d ago
434
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Subscription tracker for apps and general contracts”

Crowded and unfocused, but commercial contract renewals for procurement teams could be the wedge people actually pay for.

2/10
15d ago
435
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Waste water marketplace”

Too vague to test, and in wastewater, incumbents own the pipes, permits, and trust.

2/10
15d ago
436
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Uber for waste water”

Regulated, consolidated, and permit-bound, this dies before day one unless you find one desperate buyer with a real dispatch pain.

2/10
15d ago
437
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Waste water collection marketplace”

Regulated utility, entrenched operators, no customer, this is capture-first fantasy, not a marketplace.

2/10
15d ago
438
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Waste water marketplace”

Regulated, local wastewater markets leave little room for a marketplace, unless you own a painful industrial niche first.

2/10
15d ago
439
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Waste water marketplace”

Real wedge in industrial reuse, but right now you're selling a marketplace to regulations, assumptions, and nobody specific.

2/10
15d ago
440
ROASTEDFree Triage

“a play to earn app, players need to play games on android or pc to get these tickets, using the tickets they can join tournamnets where they compete in mini games and top scores get gift card rewards”

Crowded reward loop, brutal retention cliff, and no wedge means this dies before players care.

2/10
16d ago
441
ROASTEDFree Triage

“I ahve markettign tool needa good idea to sell”

Crowded market, no buyer, no wedge, you're bringing vibes to a knife fight.

2/10
16d ago
442
ROASTEDFree Triage

“an app that allocates a time period a day to block phone use”

Real pain, no wedge, no buyer, built-in tools already own this.

2/10
16d ago
443
ROASTEDFree Triage

“A webstie where all tech events will be listed and all tech communities will have there profiles on it.”

Useful pain, impossible wedge, communities stay where their members already are.

2/10
16d ago
444
ROASTEDFree Triage

“an app helps non-native english speakers to expand their vocabulary, in which llm will generate words meaning , examples and quiz for learning and suggest users which other words should they learn daily”

Crowded market, no buyer, no edge, vocabulary alone dies as a feature, not a company.

2/10
16d ago
445
ROASTEDFree Triage

“a document workflow engine”

Crowded market, no buyer, no wedge, you are building a giveaway feature instead of a business.

2/10
16d ago
446
ROASTEDFree Triage

“flower shop, bookshop and all in one cafe in Vatican City”

Three low margin businesses, no clear customer, and a landlord who can erase you is a Vatican trap.

2/10
16d ago
447
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Creating GCSE and ALevel mind maps for maths, physics and computer science. Visually appealing, concise, easy to skim through. Quick mind refreshers before exams. Aimed for GCSE and A Level students”

Useful product, invisible business, free incumbents own attention before your prettier PDFs ever get a chance.

2/10
16d ago
448
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Selling GCSE and A level maths physics and computer science cheat sheets for GCSE and A Level students, allowing for quick mind refreshers before the real exams.”

Useful pain, toxic positioning, free incumbents own revision and schools will not touch anything called a cheat sheet.

2/10
16d ago
449
ROASTEDFree Triage

“RepEdge.ai”

Name first, problem later, buyer never, that is branding cosplay, not a startup.

2/10
16d ago
450
ROASTEDFree Triage

“A marketplace app where seller list products and customers request product. The request matches to the sellers nearby and they can chat and do sales.”

Feature, not company, until you pick one geography, one category, and one reason sellers switch.

2/10
16d ago
Page 18 of 20 · 500 entries
← PrevNext →

Want your case on the registry?

Submit for the full panel →