Product

  • Roast my idea
  • Leaderboard
  • Graveyard
  • Blog
  • Compare

Legal

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • For AI

From the blog

How to Validate a Startup IdeaWhy Most Startup Ideas FailWill People Pay for My Idea?How to Find Your Idea's Fatal FlawMy Startup Idea Already ExistsWhen to Kill a Startup IdeaStartup Idea Validation ChecklistWhy ChatGPT Can't Validate Your IdeaIs Your Startup Idea Too Niche?WorthBuild vs IdeaRoast
IDEAROASTLaunching soon on ShipBoostDang.ai
Made in Seoul · hello@idearoast.dev
Skip to main content
IDEAROAST
LeaderboardComparePricingBundlesBlogDocs
Roast →Roast my idea →

Case Registry

Every idea that went through the panel.

Ranked by survival score. Most ideas don't make it.

Total roasted

500

Avg score

3.4/10

Survived

0 of 500

Verdict:
Panel:
Sort:
326
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Un SaaS pour la création d’agents et l’utilisateur connecté des outils lui même”

Marché réel, angle absent, sans persona précis tu lances un constructeur d’agents de plus dans une foule déjà installée.

3/10
17d ago
327
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Un SaaS pour la création d’agents et l’utilisateur connecté des outils lui même”

Marché commoditisé, sans client défini vous mourrez vite, sauf si vous devenez l’agent builder de référence des PME françaises.

3/10
17d ago
328
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Un SaaS pour la création d’agents et l’utilisateur connecté des outils lui même”

Crowded market, no wedge, and self-connected tools are table stakes, so this dies unless you own a painful niche.

3/10
17d ago
329
ROASTEDFree Triage

“A platform that analyzes your content before you post it and tells you how likely it is to go viral — with a score, a breakdown, and actionable fixes.”

You cannot predict virality, and creators trust audience feedback more than a black box selling algorithmic astrology.

3/10
17d ago
330
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Un SaaS mobile first pour les indépendant immobilier”

Bon wedge mobile, mais sans douleur assez forte, les indépendants resteront sur WhatsApp et les outils gratuits.

3/10
17d ago
331
ROASTEDFree Triage

“An App to help doormans in Brazil to manage packages and automatically notify the owner of the package trough whatsapp. The doorman take a picture and this will automaticaly recognize the pre existing record of the owner of the package and send the notification trough whatsapp. to retrieve the package with the doorman the owner show the QR code or notification code”

Real workflow win, but tiny budgets and bundled incumbents make this a feature, not a surviving company.

3/10
17d ago
332
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Website that dynamically searches for day trips from users starting location and users interests, budget, and drive time”

Useful friction, but without a specific traveler and unique data, this is just nicer Google Maps.

3/10
17d ago
333
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Ayla - secure, local-first period and pregnancy app with +dark mode support”

Real sensitivity, no wedge, Flo already ships your features and users will not abandon years of history.

3/10
17d ago
334
ROASTEDFree Triage

“AI Chief of staff for Soloprenuers for handling lead generation, tax calculation and filing, client onboarding, proposal generation and follow ups.”

Too broad to win, lead gen is commodity and tax is regulated, so pick one vertical or get ignored.

3/10
18d ago
335
ROASTEDFree Triage

“iOS app where users log their job applications, with a lot of quality of life features such as statistics”

Useful dashboard, disposable habit, and no one pays to prettify a job hunt they hope ends soon.

3/10
22d ago
336
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Find tasks/issues from Slack conversations and assign them to Asana/Jira automatically”

Interesting automation, but Slack already solves the simple case, and you have not proven teams want automatic task extraction.

3/10
23d ago
337
ROASTEDFree Triage

“A language teaching tutor that is based on openclaw like infra. The mission is to teach you written language and grammar of the given language. It will hook up to your telegram or WhatsApp and "text" you and become like your buddy, just that it will teach you the language along the way”

Crowded market, no wedge, no buyer, language buddies work but Telegram alone is not a business.

3/10
24d ago
338
ROASTEDFree Triage

“A news or community app for villages.. In India. But I guess most people don't check out on this app”

Big market, weak wedge, WhatsApp already owns the village unless you enter through officials, offline use, or vernacular news.

3/10
24d ago
339
ROASTEDFree Triage

“A ERP tool for schools”

Crowded market, vague wedge, brutal school sales, this dies before the first RFP.

3/10
24d ago
340
ROASTEDFree Triage

“I built a small tool to solve something that was annoying me while using AI for development. When I test my app on my phone and want to show a bug to Claude/ChatGPT, I keep doing this: - take screenshot - send to myself (WhatsApp/Telegram) - open on PC - download - upload to AI I was doing this 20+ times a day and it was breaking my flow. So I built a simple tool: Phone screenshot → instantly appears on PC (clipboard) Still rough, but it saves a lot of time for me. Curious — is this just my workflow, or do others face this too?”

Good pain, but today it is a personal shortcut, not a market, because existing habits already solve it well enough.

3/10
25d ago
341
ROASTEDFree Triage

“A scope creep management tool for freelancers.”

Real pain, but freelancers fix scope creep with better pricing, not another tool.

3/10
25d ago
342
ROASTEDFree Triage

“an AI tool to help people reach their goals. it sets the goals and plans out for them. it is relentless and persistently harsh on them to ensure they keep pushing. It adapts to real world changes in schedules.”

Crowded market, unproven demand, only dynamic rescheduling looks defensible if it measurably changes behavior.

3/10
26d ago
343
ROASTEDFree Triage

“The Problem: In 2026, AI-generated code and data often lack a company’s specific "tribal knowledge" (naming conventions, security protocols, or internal architecture). Developers spend hours "janitorial cleaning" AI results to make them fit their specific standards. The Solution: An API where a developer sends [AI Output] + [Internal Standards Doc] and gets back [Standardized Data]. It acts as a middleware validator that ensures AI-generated content (like code or customer responses) follows a company's "Private Brand/Code Book." How to Get Paid: Usage-based credits via a gateway like Zuplo. Offer a "Developer Free Tier" for up to 100 checks/month. How to Market: Create a "Check my AI code" VS Code extension that uses your API. Every time a developer sees a "Fix" suggestion that follows their company style, they see your brand.”

Clever wedge, but native IDE features already eat the painkiller and your freemium economics bleed before conversion.

3/10
26d ago
344
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Shopify-based skincare, cosmetics, and personal-care brands with 50–2,000 SKUs/variants, owned inventory, batch/lot tracking needs, seasonal launches, bundles, and recurring promotions. I built an e2e automation tool that manages stock units, price of products, discounts periods and creates bundles based on demand.”

Real pain, crowded shelf, without a narrow beauty buyer and proven margin lift, this dies in the Shopify app graveyard.

3/10
27d ago
345
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Roast my PropTech landing page — built for UK letting agencies. PropFlow helps agencies survive the post-Section 21 compliance wave. Compliance, documents, maintenance, rent and landlord comms — all linked to your real portfolio. Live demo, no signup: https://letting-flow-master.lovable.app/ Is the value prop clear? Does the demo actually sell it? Be brutal.”

Good pain, crowded aisle, your demo looks tidy but not painful enough to justify switching.

3/10
28d ago
346
ROASTEDFree Triage

“To build a review website for cloud kitchens and ordinary restaurants, and use a separate subsection , where there would be verified reviews, whose bills would be verified by multiple AIs, to prevent hate reviews or bot reviews.”

Real wedge, no customer, and incumbents already own review verification at scale.

3/10
28d ago
347
ROASTEDFree Triage

“I started thinking and scavaging reddit, and i think i came up with an idea. I see that a lot of people complain about (vibe)coding communitys being way too overcomplicated with bs advice and spam posts, so beginners don't know where to look and experts don't know how to give back to the community. So i'm building an community app that is mostly run by the people using the app and where beginners and experts can ask and give advice so everybody has a place. I'm also thinking about being able to create courses and guides. All of this while AI and moderators keep the community clean and usefull without any spam posts or posts that just don't belong there 1 thing that i am certain i will NOT do is implement a hard paywall, i think most knowledge should be free. However i will be implemenrknf a soft paywall because i still need to run everything ofcourse😭. I'm curious, what features would you guys like to have in this new app?”

Clear demand, captured already, and your soft paywall taxes a community that expects free help.

3/10
28d ago
348
ROASTEDFree Triage

“Shelf-Life Intelligence for Food Manufacturers 💡 Problem Food manufacturers use conservative static expiry dates. That creates enormous waste from products that are still safe/good: dairy packaged meals bakery sauces refrigerated products Millions are discarded because labels are blunt estimates. 🚀 Solution AI + data platform that dynamically estimates real shelf life using: temperature excursion data logistics history warehouse conditions product type batch characteristics Instead of: Expires in 10 days You know: This batch still has 6 safe days left This batch has only 2 days left”

Real waste, impossible wedge, lawyers will kill dynamic expiry before operations ever tests it.

3/10
28d ago
349
ROASTEDFree Triage

“BankConvert is a web-based tool designed to automatically turn PDF bank statements into organized Excel or CSV spreadsheets. It eliminates the need to manually copy and paste transaction data, which usually takes hours, and finishes the job in about 30 seconds. How it Works Upload: You drag and drop your PDF (up to 200+ pages) into the browser. Extract: The tool identifies dates, descriptions, debits, and credits with 99.9% accuracy. Download: You get a clean .xlsx file ready for Excel, Google Sheets, or accounting software like QuickBooks. Key Features Privacy First: All processing happens directly in your browser. Your financial data is never sent to a server or stored online. Universal Support: It works with over 1,000 banks worldwide (Chase, Wells Fargo, etc.). Error Detection: It flags "uncertain" rows for you to double-check before exporting. No Barriers: You can try it for free (up to 5 conversions) without creating an account or entering credit card info. Pricing Plans Plan Price Best For Free $0 Casual use (5 pages/week). Starter $9/mo Individuals (~150 pages/month). Pro $24/mo Growing businesses (600 pages/month + priority support). Business $59/mo Teams and high volume (2,500 pages/month + API access). In short: It’s a specialized converter for accountants and business owners that turns "un-copyable" bank documents into usable data instantly and privately.”

Clever privacy angle, but direct bank feeds killed this workflow and PDF parsing will drown you in brittle edge cases.

3/10
29d ago
350
ROASTEDFree Triage

“The idea: A mobile app where sellers upload 15-30 second reels of their products. Users scroll vertically (like TikTok) to discover random products. When they tap a seller's profile, they see that seller's top-selling products and current offers in their bio. My main worry: Sellers won't actually make the reels. Most small business owners are not content creators. What will kill this idea first? Have you tried something similar? What happened? If you were a seller, would you upload reels? Why or why not?”

Sellers won't make the reels, so the feed dies before buyers ever get a reason to care.

3/10
29d ago
Page 14 of 20 · 500 entries
← PrevNext →

Want your case on the registry?

Submit for the full panel →